Showing posts with label Isaac Taylor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Isaac Taylor. Show all posts

Thursday, August 13, 2026

Newspaper Article On the "Juiciest Scandal" of Early North Alabama Methodism

I have written about my ancestors, Rev. Isaac and Hannah Taylor, who were embroiled in what I call the "juiciest scandal" of early North Alabama Methodist history.

With the help of Artificial Intelligence, I found definitive proof that Isaac didn't murder Hannah. She left him and her children for another man.

For background, Isaac is buried in the middle of the Taylor Memorial Methodist Church graveyard near Trussville, Alabama. His grave is next to his brother, Rev. William Taylor, who founded the church. My mother's paper (see the link on the top left of this blog) describes the sordid affair around Isaac and Hannah. For additional information around the story, click his label on the left side of this blog.

The synopsis is that Isaac, my 3rd great grandfather, was one of three brothers who were prominent early North Alabama Methodist preachers. He was licensed to preach in 1824. But in about 1832, his wife Hannah (whose maiden name was, humorously, "Hopper") eloped with another lover and left him with three children, one of which was still nursing. My ancestor, the middle child, was only about 7 years old. Folks just couldn't imagine her leaving her children. Some bones were found nearby, leading to a conspiracy theory that he must have murdered her.

Never mind that Isaac had reported she eloped with someone. The "enemies of Methodism" took advantage of this to spread rumors and stain the reputation of the church. Whether they were eager for propaganda to antagonize the church because of their distaste for emotional revivals, the position of the church on temperance, or even issues emerging around slavery, we will never know.

Isaac was cleared of all charges, and eventually someone spotted Hannah with her new husband in Texas. Despite persistent slander, he was fully ordained four years after she left him and became a circuit rider, appointed from 1836-1840 in places such as Brandon, Mississippi and Decatur, Alabama. As a side note, my wife's ancestor, John G. Jones, was a church historian and reported that his approval at annual conference for ordination was tricky, because he was uneducated and uncouth. But he was ordained, riding the circuit for four subsequent years. 

In 1840 he "located" (a term for elders who no longer preached on horseback and settled, but often kept pastoring). According to his gravestone, he preached for 50 years. That means after he "located" and left the itineracy, he preached for some 34 more years in the Cedar Mountain (Trussville) area. Obviously, he recovered from all this.

BUT HERE'S WHAT MY MOTHER AND I NEVER KNEW!

I found an abstract of a news article published on April 22, 1842 in the "Western Weekly Review" of Franklin, Tennessee. It knocked my socks off. The editor had apparently received a letter from the lover my ancestor Hannah had eloped with a decade earlier. Her dying wish was to come clean. Here it is, with all the juicy details!

The Lost Wife

A STRANGE MYSTERY OF LOVE AND CRIME DEVELOPED

          Some 10 or 11 years ago, the wife of the Rev. Isaac Taylor, of the M. E. Church, Jefferson County, Ala., was residing. The circumstances of the case are somewhat as follows, as related by Mr. Taylor: She laid down at night as usual; some time in the night she was up and down two or three times, going out of doors and coming in again; she then took the least child an infant at the breast, kissed it and then laid it in Mr. Taylors arms, told him to keep it till she returned, and left the house and returned no more; the next day he made known her elopement to his friends; search was made from time to time, by perhaps hundreds of persons, but to no purpose. Various were the rumors put in circulation from year to year, and as various were the surmises of the public. Taylor was persecuted in some places, the church would not hear him preach, though he has continued to labor in the ministry and assert his innocency; yet public suspicion rested upon him.

          After the lapse of six years, he married a second wife, and it is said by his neighbors that all the time his moral character was without exception. After his wife was missing, he moved from the place, the premises was occupied by another family; they set fire to a large hollow stump in the field no great distance from the house; after the stump was consumed, there were bones found where it stood; the neighbors collected together, had a warrant issued for Taylor, he was arrested, taken before a Justice of the Peace, committed, and stood his trial at the regular term of the Circuit Court for Jefferson County; there being no proof against him, he was acquitted. The matter then rested until now. Very recently, the letter, (a copy of which I enclose in the present communication,) was received at Blountsville, directed to the Post Master of that place, post marked Brooklin, Mississippi, --

          The circumstances all together are so strange and singular, that I have thought they would be interesting to the public, and with a view that it may cast further light on the subject, I send them to you and request that you will give them a place in your valuable and widely circulating Journal.

I am, with respect,

Yours &c.

San Augustine, Texas, Nov. 26th, 1841.

--

To the Citizens of Blountsville, Ala. and its vicinity.

          I expect you will be very much surprised to receive a communication of this kind; but my conscience compels me to disclose the matter. I expect you all will recollect the circumstances of Isaac Taylor's wife leaving the county, and no person knew how, when nor where she went. By this, you will see that about two weeks previous to her leaving, I happened at Taylor's house and he was absent. His wife and I got to talk over old matters — Before I go any further I will tell you how she and I were engaged to be married before Taylor ever courted her, and she told me that in her present situation she was perfectly miserable, and that she had rather die than to live with Taylor another year. She at last said I was the object of her love and Taylor the cause of her misery. — She also said if I was willing, she would start with me to Texas. The next day I told her to prepare herself with men's clothing by that day two weeks, and between 10 and 3 o'clock at night I would be there and ready to start to Texas. She then insisted to carry her youngest child; I told her it would not do, and she agreed to leave all, so the time arrived and according to agreement I came and found her in readiness. I had two first rate horses, and they well rigged; she mounted one and I the other, and we set sail for the Mississippi. After we had traveled about four miles, we left the road about 250 yards and alighted, and she put on her coat, waistcoat and pants and I cut off her hair, and we mounted and again set sail, and by daylight we were about twenty miles from Taylor's. We cheerfully pursued on our journey, and arrived in Vicksburg on the 6th day after we started; by this time she was a very snug looking man. We sold our horses and took passage for New Orleans; the 5th day we arrived safe in New Orleans; we then got passage on board of a schooner to Galveston Island in Texas, and owing to the unfavorable winds, were 19 days getting to Galveston, then we arrived safe and sound. After staying there four days we went to San Phillippi on horses; she was still a man; we did not like this, and we started back to Nacogdoches, and on the way she shifted clothes, and became a woman again. We lived in the vicinity of Nacogdoches until 1836, and during this time a host of the Boxes, from Blount, moved in. I accordingly met with Wm. Box, and lay at old Pullin's and my wife was present, and Bill eyed her so close, we moved immediately to the Sulpher Fork of Red River, and there remained until last fall, when my wife took the congestive fever and died. On her death bed she requested me to do what I am now doing. I was back in Nacogdoches in '39 and '40, and I found half of Blount county there; even little Henderson, Parmer, Green, Harrison, Jim Brown, and all the Boxes in the world. I leave the matter with you, without giving any names. I would give names but I am afraid of being murdered by some of the friends of the parties. Adieu! Adieu!

Sunday, July 15, 2012

Top Ten Things a Hamby Should Know
#6 – WE DESCEND FROM A LEGACY OF METHODIST CIRCUIT RIDERS IN MISSISSIPPI AND ALABAMA

The Methodist faith spread like wildfire on the frontiers of America because of faithful people ordained to be traveling preachers. Our Taylor ancestors were heavily involved in the spreading of Christian faith in our state. Shortly after the War of 1812, when North Alabama became open to white settlement, our ancestors George and Nancy Taylor migrated to the Clay area of Jefferson County. When their sons were baptized by a Methodist circuit rider, he prayed that all the boys would become Methodist preachers. Three of the four of them did: William Taylor, Harris Taylor, and Isaac Taylor (our ancestor). They responded to the call during the 1820’s and 1830’s.

William Taylor, our third great uncle, founded Taylor Memorial United Methodist Church in Chalkville as a circuit rider, preaching at the local Sweeny Hollow water hole. Our ancestor, Isaac, is buried next to him in the graveyard there. Their graves hold inspiring inscriptions that remind me of their commitment to the gospel.

The colorful part of the story is that our third great grandmother, Hannah Hopper Taylor, left Isaac and created a scandal in early Alabama Methodism. No one could imagine her leaving her kids, including a nursing child. Rumors began to spread that he had murdered her, and bones were found. Opponents of Methodism took advantage of this. Eventually, his name was cleared by a preacher named William Blackburn, who was traveling through Texas and saw Hannah in a store with her new husband she had eloped with.

I have traced some of our ancestor, Isaac’s, circuit riding career in Mississippi. Brandon Memorial United Methodist Church in Brandon, Mississippi, is the largest present church he once served. At that time, Mississippi and Alabama were in the same Annual Conference.

My mom (Betty West) wrote an extensive paper for the North Alabama Conference Historical Society on the Taylor legacy. I have published it on my blog for all to see. Simply click the link on the left side of this blog.

Attached is a picture of five generations, tracing our connection to the Taylors. Grandpa Hamby is on the top left. Moving clockwise, next is his daughter Willie, his mother Laura Clark Hamby holding Willie’s baby, and his grandmother, Louisa Taylor Clark. Louisa’s father was Rev. Isaac Taylor.

Friday, June 8, 2012

The Lugene Hamby Window at Trinity UMC

One of the large stained glass windows at Trinity UMC in Tuscaloosa, adjacent to the campus of the University of Alabama, is named after my Grandpa Hamby's brother Lugene Bryant (Gene) Hamby. In the memorial information on my grand uncle, it makes note of our Taylor legacy.

The memorial information on the window and the life of Gene Hamby is below. Trinity UMC was once called Brandon Memorial Methodist Church. To see the window and the original memorial, check out the Glastonbury Thorn window.  

The Glastonbury Thorn Window

The Nativity
The first window nearest the back of the church contains Glastonbury thorn blossoms, a peculiarly English symbol which represents the events attending our Lord's birth.  According to tradition, the ancient thorn-tree which stands just within the gates of the ruined abbey at Glastonbury, Somersetshire, is a descendent of the thornwood staff planted by St. Joseph of Arimathaea, who is said to have introduced Christianity into England in the Year A.D. 63.  The Glastonbury thorn bursts into bloom about Christmas Day each year, and the blossoms have become a symbol of our Lord's Nativity.

This window was given by the Log Cabin Bible Class of Brandon Memorial Methodist Church in memory of Lugene ("Gene") Bryant Hamby.

Lugene Bryant Hamby
1879 - 1942

Lugene Bryant Hamby was an active member of Brandon Memorial Methodist Church for many years.  He was a member of the Board of Stewards and served as Chairman of the Board.  He was proprietor of the Hamby Barber Shop on Greensboro Avenue in Tuscaloosa.  Mr. and Mrs. Hamby and their eight children lived on 10th Street, right across from Brandon Memorial, and the whole family was involved in the work of the church.

Lugene Bryant was born October 20, 1879, one of seven sons of George Hamby, a Confederate veteran, and Laura Clark Hamby.  There was also one daughter. His parents were also members of Brandon Memorial.  His great-grandfather, Isaac Taylor, was a Methodist Circuit Rider, and two of his brothers, William T. and Charles P., were ministers in the North Alabama Methodist Conference.  His father-in-law John Alexander was a Methodist Circuit Rider in Mississippi, and his son Gene Malcolm (Mack) Hamby was a minister and conference evangelist in the North Alabama Conference.  Many other family members served the Methodist Church, both as ministers and as lay people.

Mr. and Mrs. Hamby were the parents of four sons and four daughters.  The tragedy of their lives was the death of their youngest son Bobby in 1937 at the age of 15.  Bobby was an honor student and an active member of the church youth group.  A scrapbook made by one of  Bobby’s sisters showed the love and support the family received at that time from the good members of Brandon Memorial. 

On March 24, 1942, Lugene Bryant Hamby died unexpectedly of a heart attack while visiting a neighbor near his home on 10th Street, and is buried with other family members at Evergreen Cemetery.   Honorary pallbearers were the members of the Board of Stewards of Brandon Memorial Methodist Church.

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Note on Rev. William B. Blackburn Solving the Isaac Taylor "Crime"

I found this article by a Blackburn descendant. It clarifies not only who cleared Isaac Taylor's name, something my mother didn't know, but also how the Blackburn pastors wind up on my family tree.

--------------------

A few notes on the Taylor brothers - Isaac’s father, George Taylor, came to Blount County. A Revolutionary War veteran and devout Methodist, George Taylor was present when all four of his sons were baptized on the same occasion and heard Reverend James Axley pray that all might become ministers. Three of the boys – Isaac, William, and Harris – did in fact answer the call. The Taylor family settled on Cedar Mountain and built a Methodist Church named Shiloh.

Reverend Isaac Taylor and his wife Hannah were residents of the Cedar Mountain community when Hannah disappeared between dusk and dawn on a spring day in 1832. Her disappearance caused a sensation for she left not only Isaac but six young children including one infant who was still nursing. No one in the Shiloh Church or community could imagine Hannah leaving on her own. Soon there was talk that Isaac had not searched very hard for his wife and when some bones were found in the trunk of a tree, Isaac was arrested. On close examination the bones proved to be animal remains; and as there was no evidence linking Isaac to a crime other than speculation, the grand jury failed to charge him. His good name was ruined just the same. To his credit Isaac Taylor maintained his faith and continued his ministry “exulting in the consolation of the Gospel.”

Six years passed before William Baxter Blackburn solved the “crime.” While in a store in Texas, William saw Hannah Taylor with a man he recognized from Blount County. Spotting William, Hannah quickly left the store. William returned to Alabama and added the final chapter to the case of the missing wife. Hannah’s disappearance and “elopement” enthralled the community for a generation becoming a part of area folklore and inspiring at least one bad poem.

The Blackburn family remembered the story longer than most. For when Malissa died in 1848 leaving William a widower with eight small children, he married Isaac Taylor’s niece, Lydia. By the time my mother heard the story, the search for Hannah Taylor had become the reason William Blackburn traveled to Texas – only one of several times William visited the state according to Koger Blackburn. Soon after his marriage to Lydia Taylor, William Blackburn was licensed to preach in the Methodist Church. His new father-in-law, William Taylor, had founded a church at Cedar Mountain now named “Taylor Memorial United Methodist Church” in the Chalkville area of Trussville, where he is buried. William Taylor was remembered by historian Anson West as “an able preacher, a man of more than ordinary powers of intellect … (who) maintained a good name and was loved by the people among whom he exercised his ministry.” The description of William Taylor by Anson West is not mere flattery for in the same text West describes other preachers in far less favorable terms.

Thursday, March 10, 2011

A Church Isaac Taylor Served

This is present day First United Methodist Church in Brandon, Mississippi. I took this picture on a recent vacation with the family. Brandon is just off I-20 east of Jackson.

I have confirmed with their local church historian that Rev. Isaac Taylor, my ancestor, was pastor of the church from 1838-1840. He was their third pastor.

At that time, North Alabama was part of the Mississippi Conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church.




Saturday, March 5, 2011

Isaac Taylor's Appointment History

In that time, to be "located" means you were no longer a circuit traveler but had located with a particular local church.

--------------

Dear Mr. West:

Thank you for your request for information on Rev. Isaac Taylor. I searched the General Minutes of the Methodist Episcopal Church and found the following:

MISSISSIPPI CONFERENCE
1836-37 Admitted on trial. Appointed to Louisville in the Holly Springs District
1838 Admitted into Full Connection. Appointed to Rankin in the Brandon District
1839 Serving as a Deacon. Appointed to the Decatur Mission in the Paulding District
1840 Located

There was a British Methodist author with the same name born in 1787 and died in 1865. For information please visit:
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~taylorsofongar/

I hope this is of help.

Sincerely,
Reference Archivist

The General Commission on Archives and History of The United Methodist Church
PO Box 127
Madison NJ 07940
Tel: 973-408-3196

Saturday, February 19, 2011

Granny Clark's Grave

Granny Clark grave at Cottondale Nature Garden. Louisa Taylor Clark was the daughter of Rev. Isaac Taylor and Hannah Hopper Taylor. She was born June 26, 1825 and died March 5, 1920.

The marker reads:

Louisa Clark
Wife of William Clark
1825-1920

Saturday, February 5, 2011

Friday, January 21, 2011

Isaac Taylor Grave

This was originally posted on my blog "Musings of a Musical Preacher."


I recently had another opportunity to visit the grave of my great, great, great grandfather, the Rev. Isaac Taylor. He was a Methodist circuit rider and preacher during the 1820's during the early waves of Methodism in Alabama and Mississippi (it was one conference at that time). His body is buried in the graveyard of Taylor Memorial UMC near Trussville, Alabama. The church is named after his brother, Rev. William Taylor, the pastor who founded the church.

It is always a holy moment to stand at his grave, and I do so from time to time. Years ago, I had been praying about some of the difficulties we face in the United Methodist Church, wondering if we would face structural division in my lifetime. I stood at his grave weeping and a wave of peace came over me. It is as if the Spirit spoke, saying "Steve, you were ordained in the United Methodist Church. Your father was ordained in the Methodist Church. Your grandfathers were ordained in the Methodist Episcopal Church, South. Taylor was ordained in the Methodist Episcopal Church. It doesn't matter what you call it. It will never matter how you organize it, for the fire of Wesleyan faith will keep burning." I recalled that during his ministry, the church divided over issues of slavery.

I began a long process of letting go and trusting God for the future. My ministry has been a journey of realizing that I am stepping into a larger picture of the Spirit's movement across many generations. This brings me great peace and a sense of context. It is not up to me to fix the larger issues. It is my calling to serve the gospel faithfully and trust God for the rest. The future belongs to God.

His grave stone reads:

In memory of
Rev. ISAAC TAYLOR
was born January 27th, 1802
died May 5th, 1871
He was a minister of the gospel 50 years
and died in the hope
& Consolation of the same.
---------------
"Blessed are the dead
who die in the Lord."




Saturday, January 8, 2011

Five Generations of Taylors

This is my grandfather, Rev. C.P. Hamby, Sr, among five generations of Taylors! The picture was taken in about 1920, just before Grannie Clark died.






















Back Row L-R: Charles Pinkney Hamby, Sr. and his daughter, Willie Hamby Shelton
Front Row L-R: Louisa Taylor Clark (daughter of Isaac Taylor), Laura Frances Hamby (C.P's mother, Louisa Clark's daughter), Willie's oldest baby, Charles

Friday, January 7, 2011

Pastors Among the Taylor Descendants

This is part 5 of the paper Betty Hamby West presented to the North Alabama Conference Historical Society.

William, Isaac, and Harris Taylor presumably were all licensed local preachers, although I could only confirm this for Harris. Anson West writes, "He was a local preacher and associated with the Talladega Circuit until his death in 1852" (475). All three brothers settled in an area where they preached and ministered. William Sweet, in discussing early Methodist Circuit Riders, says: "When a preacher married, it was usually necessary for him to locate, that is, he stopped traveling a circuit and settled down on a farm...and although most of them continued their interest in the church and preached frequently in their vicinity, their names disappeared from the list of active preachers in the 'Minutes' and they then had the status of local preachers" (145). This explains why I could find no Taylors listed in the journals of the Mississippi or Alabama Conferences. The North Alabama area was a part of each of these conferences at different times during the span of their ministry.

The fact that the Taylors settled and remained in one general area during their active years explains the deep affection and reverence their parishioners felt for them. Anson West closes his discussion of their lives and ministry with the following: "Beyond doubt the four sons of George Taylor were men of extraordinary gifts and power, and it is equally certain that God's ear was attent unto the prayers which the Rev. James Axley made for them at their baptism, and in answer to that prayer the Lord God remembered them for good, and upon them put His blessing forever, and with the gifts of the Holy Spirit they were endowed, and extraordinary manifestations attended them (292). Marion Lazenby, extolling the Taylors writes: "No man can estimate the good George Taylor and his wife did, in their own right, and in bringing into the world so useful a family. It was of their kind that Jesus spoke when he said, 'Ye are the salt of the earth' " (141).

As I pondered these tributes to the pioneer George Taylor family, I could visualize a great host of their descendants, both lay people and ministers, all over the North Alabama Conference. One of George and Nancy Taylor's daughters, Catherine, married Elijah Self, who also joined Shiloh Church the year it was organized. He was class leader and local preacher there. Their son, Nathaniel, was an itinerate preacher. He was admitted to the Alabama conference in 1855 while two of his uncles, William and Isaac, were still active (Lazenby 299). Nathaniel died in 1894 (NAC Journal 47). That same year Will Hamby, a great grandson of Isaac Taylor, was licensed to preach in what had become the North Alabama Conference (Lazenby 920). In 1908 he was followed into the ministry by his younger brother and my father, Charles P. Hamby (543). In 1934 while Will and Charlie Hamby were both active in the conference, their nephew, Gene Malcolm Hamby, a great great-grandson of Isaac Taylor, became a member of the conference (757). In 1950, while their first cousin Gene Malcolm was still active in the conference, Charles P. Hamby, Jr. and Warren Candler Hamby were admitted on trial (931). In 1959 Edwin Self, who is a great-great grandson of Elijah Self and Catherine Taylor, was admitted to the conference and is still active in retirement. In 1961, Gordon Ware, also a great-great grandson of Elijah and Catherine, was admitted to the conference where he served faithfully until his death. Warren Hamby, who is still a member of this conference, has been blessed to see his nephew, Stephen Pierce West, ordained; and later his daughter, Jan Hamby Piper, assigned as a student local pastor. Both Steve and Jan are great-greatgreat grandchildren of Isaac Taylor. In researching these dates I discovered that from 1820, when William Taylor was licensed to preach, until the present time, 2002, for 182 consecutive years there has been one or more of the descendants of George and Nancy Taylor among the clergy of the area that is now the North Alabama Conference. There have been thirteen ministerial descendants in all. Praise God for the devotion of these pioneer Methodist ancestors. As Lazenby said, "It was of their kind that Jesus spoke when he said 'Ye are the salt of the earth' " (141).

WORKS CITED

Bryant, Cindy. Taylor Memorial United Methodist Church History. Chalkville, 1983.

Davenport, G.M. "Obituaries: Charles P. Hamby." Alabama Christian

Advocate. February 26, 1952.

Goodwin, Glenda. Interview. 2002.

Hamby, Gene Malcolm. Taped interview. Decatur: 1980.

Joiner, Harry M. Alabama's History the Past and Present. Athens: Southern Textbook Publishers, 1980.

Lazenby, Marion Elias. History of Methodism in Alabama and West Florida.

Parthenon Press: 1960.

Self, Hartford T. History of Clay United Methodist Church. Clay, Alabama. Clay UMC: 1993.

Self, Hartford T. Interview. 2002.

Summersell, Charles Grayson. Alabama History for Schools. Montgomery: Viewpoint Publications, Inc., 1970.

Sweet, William Warren. Methodism in American History. New York: The Methodist Book Concern, 1933.

West, Anson. A History of Methodism in Alabama. Nashville: Publishing

House Methodist Episcopal Church South, 1893.

Friday, December 31, 2010

Isaac Taylor (1802-1874)

This is part 4 of the paper Betty Hamby West presented to the North Alabama Conference Historical Society.

It was no surprise to me to discover that the middle Taylor brother, the one from whom I am descended, Isaac, was the colorful and controversial character among the three preacher brothers. He was my great- great grandfather. The second child of Isaac Taylor and Hannah Hopper, Louisa, married William Clark. Their daughter, Laura Frances Clark, married George W. Hamby. Their son, Charles P. Hamby, was my father. Louisa Taylor Clark was my great grandmother. She is buried in the Cottondale Nature Gardens Cemetery near Tuscaloosa, Alabama.

Isaac Taylor was licensed to preach by the quarterly conference of the Jones Valley Circuit upon a recommendation from the society at Cedar Mountain in 1824. The watershed event of his life occurred about 1832. He then had a wife, Hannah, and six children aged 11 down to a nursing infant. They lived only a couple of miles from the Shiloh church. One night, between bedtime and dawn, his wife disappeared. The mystery caused a sensation in the community, especially among the enemies of Methodism. It was soon whispered about that the Rev. Isaac Taylor had killed his wife. The main evidence against him was the presumption that it was unnatural for a woman to leave her own children. The climax came when some bones that were found in the forest near the Taylor farm were exhibited as bones of the missing woman. Isaac was arrested. However, after all the sensation and excitement, the grand jury never indicted him. He was eventually exonerated, but not before his life and ministry had been damaged (West 289). The theory which solved the mystery was elopement: a man who moved from the Cedar Mountain region to Texas, and who knew Isaac Taylor and his wife intimately, was one day in a Texas store when a man and woman walked in. He immediately recognized the woman as the missing wife of Rev. Taylor and he saw that she recognized him. Without speaking a word, she and the man with her left the store. The story that evolved was that she had left home disguised as a boy with a man who lived near her; that they had gone through obscure regions, using deserted Indian trails, and continued on to the Republic of Texas. This theory was corroborated by the memory of her oldest child of the day of her disappearance. On that day, he and his mother had been dropping com in the field, and they went together to the house for her to nurse the baby. He recalled that as she nursed the infant he saw a sad expression cover his mother's face (290). A final support for this theory was made by Rev. Taylor himself on his death bed. In conversation with one of his friends, in alluding to his credentials, he said: "These papers I have never dishonored. In the pulpit I have never uttered a word which I would rescind" (289).

I have read this account in Anson West several times and tried to imagine the circumstances of Isaac and Hannah's life. Today, with our knowledge of post-partum depression and emotional stress, it is not difficult to believe that a woman with the responsibilities of six small children, all the domestic work, and most of the farm work; a woman with a husband who was off riding the circuit, and rarely there to support her, might choose to escape from it all. This is more easily imagined than that a man would murder a wife and become himself solely responsible for all these duties.

The dark shadow over Isaac's life did not stop his preaching nor totally mar his influence. The epitaph on his headstone, in the Taylor's Chapel cemetery, reads "He was a minister of the gospel 50 years and died in the hope and consolation of the same." In 1990 I interviewed an older first cousin, Rev. Mack Hamby, who has since deceased, and questioned him about the Taylors. Please listen to part of the interview. (See Attachment).

Isaac Taylor married Elizabeth King in 1836, which was four years after the disappearance of his first wife.

Click "Newer Post" underneath this post to continue reading ...